Preserve Alpha disappears in Live Blur filters

[Zero1]

When using the Live Gaussian Blur, the preserve alpha checkbox is available when it is added. After closing and opening it again, the preserve Alpha checbox disappears? (Same happens with box blur and probably with other blurs too)

 

 

Also interesting enough, after pressing the merge button, the filter is blocked for editing (the edit dialog does not come up) until you select another layer and switch back, then the edit dialog comes up again?

BTW any idea what the merge button does??

[loukash]

2 hours ago, Zero1 said:

any idea what the merge button does??

It applies the filter destructively on the next pixel layer below.

[Zero1]

1 hour ago, loukash said:

It applies the filter destructively on the next pixel layer below.

Thank you for clearing that out.. that was also my expectation (destructively applied(, however as i am mostly working with image layers, nothing was happening. Pixel layer was the magic word here

I would suggest that when the filter is a child of an image layer, to hide this button or have the image layer rasterize to pixel (with a warning from assistant), which would make more sense. Secondly it is kind of strange behaviour when the (blur) filter in on top of image layer and a pixel layer is below it. The image layer gets blurred when merge is pressed, it skips the image layer and merges with the pixel layer below. It makes sense but i don't think that is expected behavior.

[loukash]

3 minutes ago, Zero1 said:

I would suggest that when the filter is a child of an image layer, to hide this button

No, because you can also have another pixel layer as a child of the image layer, and you may want to merge the filter into that one. 
The possibilites are immense.  

[Zero1]

1 minute ago, loukash said:

No, because you can also have another pixel layer as a child of the image layer, and you may want to merge the filter into that one. 
The possibilites are immense.  

Haha, that is true, but still think it is detectable whether the merge is going to apply to the "parent" image or a child pixel... (at the end it applies to something and is processed if applicable, so it can be detected too...). Maybe hiding the button would case confusion (why not shown etc), but rasterizing the image layer would make sense.

[loukash]

26 minutes ago, Zero1 said:

hiding the button

Hiding something is a bad UI idea. If a function is unavailable, then it has to be "grayed out".

[walt.farrell]

4 hours ago, Zero1 said:

When using the Live Gaussian Blur, the preserve alpha checkbox is available when it is added. After closing and opening it again, the preserve Alpha checbox disappears?

Getting back to your original question, which I think we have not addressed: The Preserve Alpha checkbo does not disappear on Windows when the Live Filter layer is closed and reopened. At least for the file I tried it on.

[Zero1]

1 hour ago, loukash said:

Hiding something is a bad UI idea. If a function is unavailable, then it has to be "grayed out".

You are completely right! Which brings us to the original question A checkbox is being hidden without reason... which is bad

[Zero1]

1 hour ago, walt.farrell said:

Getting back to your original question, which I think we have not addressed: The Preserve Alpha checkbo does not disappear on Windows when the Live Filter layer is closed and reopened. At least for the file I tried it on.

That is why this post is in macOS Beta forum

[Gabe]

Thanks. Issue logged. 

[barninga]

still true on macs as today jan 5, 23