[Photo/Designer 2.2] Smudge tool scrapping off the paint

[Kemelvor]

Hello !

As I use the smudge brush more and more often, I encounter an issue I have since I started using Affinity, 3 years ago. This tools is very unreliable as it tend to scrap off the paint off the layer rather than spread it out when you use a pen.

In the first screenshot, I provided the following, from left to right :
- The brush used for the smudge. Solid round brush with a size jitter at 90%. Settings in the second screenshot.
- The smudge tool used with a pen at high strength (80%) on top, low strength (40%) on bottom.
- The same smudge tool used with my mouse. High strength on top, low strength on bottom. The issue isn't present here.

I use Huion Kamvas Pro 20 and the latest version of Affinity.

I tried the following :

• Different values of flow and strength affect the intensity of the scrapping, but it's still present especially if I apply a high pressure. Strength has way more impact than flow.
• Using textured brushes somehow lessen the undesirable effect by a lot, it's what I use currently while waiting for a fix but the scrapping is still slightly visible at high strength/high pressure (Third screenshot)
• Using other solid brushes range from similar to worse. Especially the basic brushes that come by default.
• Changing the Tablet Input Method or turning on/off the hardware acceleration does not fix the issue.
• The Force Pressure button does not fix the issue.
• Did those in Affinity Photo, but Affinity Designer has the same issue.
• Tried with another drawing software, the issue isn't present.

The issue has been reported before, here, although it's been a while.

Thank you for taking attention to my issue !

[NathanC]

Hi @Kemelvor,

I can also replicate this in 2.2.0, as you've mentioned this is an issue that has been logged previously but needed updating to reflect the current version, I've now updated the existing issue and bumped it with your report.

[Kemelvor]

Thank you very much ! Will wait for the fix with eagerness.

[Andreas Wilkens]

Hi NathanC, any news on the smudge tool bug? I have been dealing with for a long time and it stopped me from getting V2 as yet. Previously in my PS era the tool used to be extremely useful for creating hair which can't be done any more that way. Thanks for keeping us up to date.

Cheers

 

A.W.

[NathanC]

Hi @Andreas Wilkens,

No news to share unfortunately, I've updated the issue to reflect that it's still outstanding in the current version and bumped it with your report. If there are any further updates the Affinity Info Bot will automatically reply in this thread.

[Andreas Wilkens]

Hi NathanC, still wondering whether the bug mentioned in this thread still exists inside V2 of AF Photo. I couldn't find any relevant information in the current release notes which I checked today. Thanks for keeping me up to date!

A.W.

 

[Oufti]

On 5/17/2024 at 3:12 PM, NathanC said:

If there are any further updates the Affinity Info Bot will automatically reply in this thread.

Since there is no reply from the Affinity Info Bot, it means there is no update.