Jump to content
You must now use your email address to sign in [click for more info] ×

doeboy

Members
  • Posts

    63
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by doeboy

  1. Impainting tool improvement suggestions.

     

    Hi all

     

    I am new to AP. The #1 reason I bought it is for what I call garbage collection (lines, posts, signs, TV aerials, etc.): the impainting tool. OK, I am interested in others tools as well. ;-)

    I could do quick and excellent jobs but I also have been struggling in some situations. I was impressed by its performance yet I think it can be significantly improved.

    Here are some of my suggestions. I have been thinking about them long before getting AP.

     

    1. Create specific tools for specific objects to be removed, for example wires.

    I had to remove tons of them with backgrounds of either foliage or buildings. If the line is just above or just under the top of the foliage or at the edge the result is often a blurred mixture of green and blue. It works well only if the background is plain blue sky or plain foliage.

    If the background is a building and the line passes across or along such features as windows, cornices, brick chimneys and other reliefs, the tool often doesn't reproduce the right pattern. Often you then have to work by little chunks and often undo and redo until you get the right result.

     

    1.1. Wires

    A wire practically always follows a very predictable curb, has a regular width (or thickness) and a more or less consistent color (usually brown to black) or several colors when it shines under the sun light (black and whitish). It usually contrasts well with the background but can mingle with other patterns.

    The procedure would consist in:

    1.1.a. Clicking on both ends of the wire.

    1.1.b. Clicking on several spots in between so the program can calculate the curb and evaluate the width.

    1.1.c. The program would enhance the wire and allow the user to adjust the width.

     

    1.2. Posts

    I took pictures of a street art mural with posts in the foreground. Similarly they were straight, homogeneously colored (dark brown). The tool had the tendency to copy-paste the surrounding patterns, like it would do if it was grass for example. It gave a strange mirror effect with some duplicated features.

    A specific “post” tool would be able to better recognize what's to be removed and how to stitch the background pattern.

     

    1.3. Aerials

    Aerials come in many different sizes and layout but have a common pattern. Their colors are also rather typical.

    The procedure would consist in creating a polygon around the aerial.

     

    1.4. Lattice electricity pylon

    Like the aerials, they come in different shapes, patterns and sizes and, depending on their background, can be very tricky to dispose of. A “lattice” tool would probably do it more easily. In particular, instead of impainting the whole region it would be able to take into account and keep what's seen through the lattice.

     

    1.5. Branches

    I often choose to take certain shots (of buildings for example) in winter when there are no leaves blocking the view. Yet barren branches can be rather obstructing anyway. Therefore a branch tool similar to the lattice tool would be nice.

     

    1.6. Signs: One way street, No parking, etc.

    Same as for the others.

     

    2. Stitching

    I shot another mural that had two road signs in the foreground. The impainting tool did a “credible” job for the eyes of someone who can't see the original. I would say: “Well tried”. Let's say it's creative. Of course AP couldn't guess the actual features that were behind. It will do, it's minor features and people are not going to check.

    Whereas this shot was taken from right in front of the wall and therefore has only a vertical perspective deformation I also took another one from an offset position to capture the hidden parts and this shot has both horizontal and vertical deformations.

    What I have in mind is a tool that would allow to choose a region from one shot and to paste it in another shot while trying to make the perspectives match.

    In Hugin there is a Mask tool that allows to chose a region in the overlapping zones to be either included in or excluded from the final image. It's handy when a person, an animal or a car moved between two shots.

    I tried to do the job with Hugin and it was a disaster. It's obviously not its domain of competence.

    Maybe this tool would be rather tricky to develop but I know plenty of shots that I could save with such a feature.

     

    Just my 2cts.

     

    Nick

    Its called the clone tool ..

  2. What I really enjoy the most about this image is "I didn't have to scroll left or right, up and down 10 miles" just to view your work. When people post their work that are larger then this one I don't even bother looking at them.

     

    Just Beautiful Thanks for sharing.

  3. You don't think that users should still be warned and contacted by pm/email so they can remove any said posts/images etc. that some dingleberry finds offensive? Come on there has to be some type of interaction with the offender before taking action. (hope your not offended for my use of dingleberry)

     

    The whole point of a warning is to give the user an advanced notice of  "posting any material which is knowingly false and/or defamatory, inaccurate, abusive, vulgar, hateful, harassing, obscene, profane, sexually oriented, threatening".

     

    3 Strikes Rule

    1st warning remove offending content

    2nd warning account suspension (one day)

    3rd warning the user account gets deleted
     

     

  4. These are the steps I used to create the image below.

     

    1. duplicate your image ⌘+J

    2. select the duplicated image go to adjustments > HSL and move the saturation to -100%

    3. select the duplicated image and change its blend mode to color dodge then invert image the image ⌘+I

    4. image should be mostly white go to filters > blur > gaussian blur, slide the radius till you get the effect your looking for.

    To add textture go to filter noise add noise.

     

     

     

    I used this video from Blue Lightning TV

     

    Image used from
    https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Sad_Summer_Girl_Portrait.jpg

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Guidelines | We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.