Well, I have to say I just came along for the ride recently and had no expectation of a DAM, I mostly was happy to find easier to use versions of InDesig/Photoshop/illustrator tools with a traditional versioned licensing model.
Cant speak to the support offered. I’m ok with AP being just a replacement for PS.... that’s the idea. But certainly the demise of Aperture is the turning point on the DAM front.
i checked out dark table and felt like it was too sluggish, though maybe the right features...
photoSupreme didn’t seem to meet my needs well... not seem less enough with workflow.
i want something fast that I can move through a collection, tag/rate, quick adjust and crop. Then gather up those into some named bundle(preferably a ‘smart album’ and either export in bulk, or edit in external editor AND ideally have the DAM maintain versions. You know, Aperture
thanks for all the input so far
still looking through my list......