Jump to content
rjan

Burn, dodge and saturation tool tonal range settings poor

Recommended Posts

I find the difference between tonal range settings (highlights, midtones, shadows) is not very different when using the Burn, Dodge and Saturation tools. 

 

Can these tools be improved so that there's more differentiation between highlights, midtowns and shadows when using these tools?

 

Although my next question may fit better with a features request, I'd like to keep it in context because they're related; It'll be nice to be able to adjust how much one tonal range setting impinges onto the next - like a tolerance setting. This would give remarkable control over burning and dodging. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey rjan,

 

I've just done a comparison in Photoshop and I seem to be getting similar results. Have you done a comparison yourself? I'd like to see your results if you have.

 

We can move this post to Feature Requests once we have looked into the first part :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 29.07.2015 at 1:53 PM, Chris_K said:

I would have to say this is more a subjective thing and a feature request rather than a bug.

 

On 09.01.2017 at 2:46 PM, Chris B said:

I've just done a comparison in Photoshop and I seem to be getting similar results. Have you done a comparison yourself? I'd like to see your results if you have.

 

No, it's not subjective. I created a gradient from black to white, performed one brush stroke with 100% opacity, and then created a curve representing the tool effect.

 

The following two images represent how the Dodge and Burn tools work in Photoshop. The second with the Protect Tones option enabled.

 

dodge-burn-photoshop.thumb.png.29df301271f9c70a695d323b21b30f62.png

 

dodge-burn-photoshop-protect-tones.thumb.png.ffd0b93ee87e36172be54baeb062ba04.png

 

The following picture represent how it works in Affinity Photo.

 

dodge-burn-affinity-photo.thumb.png.a11a3c590f8eac84cd4d94cb0cf1d834.png

 

The Shadows is completely broken, they affects the midtones and highlights range more than the Midtones. It seems like the left part of the Burn (Shadows) graph is flipped.

 

In 16bit mode the Dodge (Midtones) is also broken.

 

dodge-burn-affinity-photo-bug.png.a23961c652ddcf72424ab57450fe46a6.png

 

Related threads:

https://forum.affinity.serif.com/index.php?/topic/48556-strange-bug-with-the-dodging-tool/

https://forum.affinity.serif.com/index.php?/topic/11559-dodge-burn-brushes-behavior-and-defaults/

https://forum.affinity.serif.com/index.php?/topic/30928-cant-burn-to-pure-black/

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

dont know if i have same issue or its something else...

im trying to do burn inside of jet thruster cone and i cant recreate it quite well with non-destructive technique (overlay) and not at all with "classic" burn tool.

Feels like burn tool is to weak any idea how to make it more brutal, darker and gritty? like in PS if you un-tick "protect tones".

Need to have that soot-like visuals.

With non destructive technique im close but still not there.

Its texture for some old game project so i dont want it take too much time its texture in style of 1998-2003 (colors, filters, fx, heavy use of Dodge and Burns...)

  PS burn:

PS-BurnAndDodge2.png

Update:

I think im closer to what i need, so i will do it with custom brush with harder and smaller pixels which i have created and using Non destructive technique (overlay).


Core i7 4770 - AMD R9 290x (Driver 18.2.3) - 32GB RAM - Asus z87-Pro - Asus Phoebus - Windows 7 x64 ultimate SP1 (monthly rollup)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×