hifred Posted November 12, 2016 Share Posted November 12, 2016 Thank you for the surprisingly quick release of Photo Beta for Windows!I have a few questions / comments on RAW editing as a heavy user of Photoshop and its upstream ACR workspace.While I like that Serif actually chose a common interface for traditional photo-retouching / compositing as well asRAW developing there's also features I miss right away.Photoshop's RAW development allows for global editing of image properties – pretty much in the way the Develop Personaworks. That way one can raise the exposure or increase contrast – changes do apply to the whole image. Apart from thatone may use any combination of tools for non-destructive brush based operations, as well as graduated filters. The impactof any contributing tool may get changed at any point in time. Even after bringing the edited RAW image into the mainPS application as a smart object and having worked for hours in a composition, one can still go back and each and any global,operation as well as brush based RAW operations are still Life. One at that point can even delete the original RAW file, asit has completely gotten embedded into the .psd. If so desired, one could strip out any changes and export to .dng again.The Affinity RAW editor seems not to have any of the tools I just described. Also, RAW development in Affinity seems to beunderstood as the first step in a linear stream of editing operations. One may of course re-enter the Develop workspace,but all tools have forgotten the settings one had dialed in initially.I wonder what your plans are in terms of RAW editing: Do you plan to keep Develop-setting Live?Is non-destructive brush / gradient-based editing with any combination of tools on the roadmap? I also wonder what happens if one uses a couple of RAW based images on a large Poster. In Photoshop one may usethese images at their full size or as a thumbnail. But one can scale that thumbnail up again or paste it into a new fileand raise the output size here. As the RAW information is encapsulated in the Smart Object one never loses resolution.Obviously one shouldn't go larger that the original RAW but for all smaller output sizes one can practically forget aboutresolution issues. Is there a similar solution inside Affinity Photo? littledetails 1 Quote [Poll] Do you need a DAM? And what should it be like? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.