Jump to content

DoctorMicro

Members
  • Content count

    8
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Reputation Activity

  1. Thanks
    DoctorMicro reacted to JET_Affinity in Envelope warping, object-distort, perspective tool or fisheye tool?   
    Practically everyone couches their pet feature desire in terms of the "most fundamental, basic, must-have deal-breaker preventing my being able to do anything with Affinity," and "the one and only thing preventing my ceasing paying Adobe's extortion fees."
    And I still say that emulating Illustrator is the last thing I want to see. I don't want "me, too"; I want better. No matter how long it takes.
    The video of using an envelope distortion in Illustrator  to apply a dimple texture to a bullet is a case-in-point, because its result is actually wrong, and not even marginally convincing.
    The view of the bullet is obviously orthographic: a "side view." Therefore, drawn correctly (or at least convincingly), the circular centerlines of all of the rows of dimple dots would appear not as curves, but as straight lines; not just in the cylindrical portion of the bullet, but in its dome as well. (Think of latitude lines on a globe when viewed the globe is oriented such that its equator is viewed "edge on.")
    In all of the rows, the dimples (and the spacing between them) would increasingly narrow in width as they progress toward either side. But in the warp result, they are of uniform width and are even wider than they are tall. In the dome portion, each dimple ellipse would also increasingly rotate depending on its elevation toward the top of the dome.
    I'm not insulting Poptoogi's drawing here; I'm just making my point about feature requests. The video used to exemplify the "critical need" is an example of the classic "golf ball" projection problem:

    Even Illustrator's 3D Effect feature cannot correctly map that texture to the half-sphere portion of the bullet, because 3D Effect's mapping onto a sphere always "pinches" the mapped artwork at the poles. But it gets worse: Even Illustrator's explicitly-named "fisheye" envelope also fails for this kind of commonly-needed distortion, resulting in a "squarish" distortion.
    That's not because automation of such a distortion is impossible in a 2D program; I've automated it myself by use of simple 2D geometry in an AI JavaScript:

    (This is not an envelope distortion, but an entirely different approach toward achieving more exactly and correctly what has been posited as an example of why envelope distortion is so "fundamentally" needed.)
    I dare say if the functionality of that JavaScript were enhanced a little bit and implemented with a nice interface in a mainstream drawing program, it could end up being called the most "fundamental, basic, must-have deal-breaker preventing my being able to do anything with [any other program]."
    That's all I'm saying: Set your goal higher than Illustrator. And be willing to wait for it. Because if you're not, we'll just end up with "me, too" functionality.
    New-from-the-ground-up Affinity is the kind of opportunity that doesn't come along very often. Let's not squander it by demanding the mediocrity of Adobe Illustrator.
    JET
  2. Like
    DoctorMicro got a reaction from cdnmoondog in Envelope warping, object-distort, perspective tool or fisheye tool?   
    I miss Macromedia too 
  3. Thanks
    DoctorMicro reacted to Patrick Connor in The Studio Link in Publisher is not recognizing my installed Designer and Photo   
    @fmz
    Welcome to the Serif Affinity forums  
    Please can you go to  "\%ProgramData%\Affinity\Common\1.0\appinfo\Release" and delete the Designer Release.appinfo.
    Once deleted, re-run both Designer and then try the StudioLink again.
  4. Like
    DoctorMicro got a reaction from Jowday in Envelope warping, object-distort, perspective tool or fisheye tool?   
    I Agree, this is needed to stay in this program without having to resort to mixing tools just to get the job done... it's FRUSTRATING!
     
    Moderator said it was on the Roadmap over 2 Years ago... this must be some Loooooog Road!
  5. Like
    DoctorMicro got a reaction from cdnmoondog in Envelope warping, object-distort, perspective tool or fisheye tool?   
    I miss Macromedia too 
  6. Like
    DoctorMicro reacted to IcyPRO in Affinity Photo and Designer 1.6 have launched!   
    Why do I have to become a detective searching for update notes every time new update rolls out?
    All the information should be written on the download page.
  7. Like
    DoctorMicro reacted to JokeRat in Affinity Photo and Designer 1.6 have launched!   
    I'm also interested in the patch/release notes for 1.6.4.
    For my everyday work it's mandatory that I know what tools/features have changed/added, etc..
     
    In my opinion (and it seems like I'm not the only one) this is something that should be very visible as soon as the update hits. especially what new features were added.
    I'd love to see a simple splash screen with 'what's new' on starting up the new version the first time with the most important changes and a link to the whole change log, without me having to search through a whole forum, just to not find any information.
     
    just my two cents...
  8. Like
    DoctorMicro got a reaction from cdnmoondog in Envelope warping, object-distort, perspective tool or fisheye tool?   
    I miss Macromedia too 
×

Important Information

These are the Terms of Use you will be asked to agree to if you join the forum. | Privacy Policy | Guidelines | We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.