Muokkaa

Hey @NotMyFault Thank you very much for your help. Since I can't send that file cause is a client thing, let me prepare a scene with some similar elements and render, and I will share it here with you. Also, thanks a lot for those links, really helpfull the one about 3d render composition. I will share those files as soon as I have them ready to go. Cheers!

I have been digging into the forum and looks like this is a problem that Affinity haven't solved yet. I have found some threads talking about the same situation with alphas and I found zero solutions for the issue. It's a pity because I just used Photoshop for 3D retouching and Affinity Photo looked like the best alternative, but it's not. I'm not saying is a bad software but, it still needs some improvements to be a good professional choice. If you find a solution for this, please keep me posted.

Hi, Same situation here but with Redshift and Cinema 4D. Looks like Affinity Photo doesn't read alphas and masks properly when importing from external software. In my case, I'm extracting some alphas from an EXR. Photoshop perfoms really nice, but Affinity Photo creates some kind of halo expanding the masks. As MBLV said, there shouldn't be any hoops to jump through or a bunch of tricks to apply for this, it should be easy for Affinity as it is for other softwares. I have attached an image to show you how the same file looks in Affinity and Photoshop. Looks like this is a bug, hopefully it's solved soon.

Hey, Thank you for reply. Unfortunately, I'm not allowed to share this image cause an NDA contract. I found another person posted the same issue a few days ago, I think it will be useful to reply and continue this coversation there. Anyway, thank for very much for your help, much appreciated.

Hi, I have just started working with Affinity Photo last week after years using Photoshop, and I have a situation with masks. I'm a 3D designer and I use Photo for retouching renders. What I usually do is to export masks from the 3D software, import those from an EXR file and put them together to apply some curves, levels and HSL to the final image. Photoshop worked perfectly but Affinity photo perfoms in a weird way generating some kind of a expansion around the masks. I have attached an image where you can compare both Photoshop and Affinity Photo results. Do you have any tip to export EXR or PNG files to avoid this kind of issue, please? Thank you for your help in advance.